Reading Skemp’s article really made me rethink how we learn math, and a few specific points definitely made me pause. First, his definition of instrumental understanding as just "rules without reasons" hits close to home; it's shocking to realize how often we just want the formula to get the homework done without actually caring about why it works. Second, the town map analogy was a huge eye-opener, it perfectly explains that feeling of being completely stranded on a test the second a question changes even a little bit because you only memorized a fixed path instead of learning the actual layout. Finally, his argument that we're basically teaching two completely different subjects under the single name of "mathematics" was pretty shocking. It makes so much sense that people develop a massive fear of math when they are forced to just memorize meaningless marks on paper rather than seeing it as a connected, living system.
Personally, I strongly side with relational understanding because trying to memorize separate, endless rules for every single problem type sounds exhausting and honestly unsustainable long-term. Even though Skemp is right that instrumental math gives you that quick boost of confidence when you get a page of right answers, it ultimately traps you. Building a mental map of what you're doing takes way more effort upfront, but it's the only way to actually retain the material and feel confident enough to figure things out on your own when a problem doesn't look exactly like the example.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Resource Review: Maths & Crafts: Art, craft, the beauty of mathematics by Jane Butterfield
For the resource review blog assignment, I checked out Maths & Crafts: Art, craft, the beauty of mathematics by Jane Butterfield. At fi...
-
It was an amazing experience; Malihe really brought a completely different perspective through her discussion with us on how language can no...
-
Group Members: Francisco, Jasmeet and Parminder Original Artwork: Desconstrucció d'un dodecàedre by Josep Rey Nadal Remaking the Origin...
-
It is often said that we usually remember our best and worst teachers and, most of the time, forget about the average ones. This is true to ...
I love Skemp’s map analogy too, especially as it highlights the fact that getting lost is intrinsic to the process of learning in a contextualized way!
ReplyDelete